The Difference Between a Handyman and a Contractor: When to Hire Each

James W.

1/27/20252 min read

man in red jacket and black pants walking on gray concrete stairs
man in red jacket and black pants walking on gray concrete stairs

When it comes to home improvement projects, knowing whether to hire a handyman or a contractor can save you time, money, and stress. Both professionals have distinct roles, and understanding their differences will help you make the right choice for your project. Here’s a comprehensive guide to when you should hire a handyman and when you need a contractor.

What Is a Handyman?

A handyman is a versatile professional skilled in handling a variety of small to medium-sized home repair and maintenance tasks. While they don’t specialize in one trade, handymen are proficient in multiple areas and are often the go-to choice for quick fixes or minor upgrades.

Common Tasks Handled by a Handyman:

  • Fixing drywall and patching holes

  • Installing shelves or curtain rods

  • Replacing light fixtures or ceiling fans

  • Painting touch-ups

  • Basic plumbing repairs, such as fixing leaks

  • Assembling furniture

When to Hire a Handyman:

  • The project is small or straightforward.

  • You have a list of unrelated minor repairs (a “honey-do list”).

  • The job doesn’t require specialized licensing or permits.

Advantages of Hiring a Handyman:

  • Cost-effective for small tasks

  • Quick turnaround for multiple jobs

  • Flexible skill set

What Is a Contractor?

A contractor is a licensed professional who specializes in a specific trade or manages larger, more complex projects. Contractors often oversee teams of specialists, ensuring that projects comply with building codes and regulations.

Common Tasks Handled by a Contractor:

  • Home renovations or remodels

  • Room additions

  • Roofing installation or repairs

  • Electrical rewiring

  • Plumbing overhauls

  • Structural repairs

When to Hire a Contractor:

  • The project requires permits or inspections.

  • Specialized expertise is necessary (e.g., HVAC installation, roofing).

  • The job involves significant structural changes.

  • You’re planning a large-scale renovation or addition.

Advantages of Hiring a Contractor:

  • In-depth expertise in a specific trade

  • Ability to manage complex projects

  • Ensures compliance with local building codes

Key Differences Between a Handyman and a Contractor

1. Licensing and Permits:

  • Handymen are typically not required to have licenses for small jobs.

  • Contractors must hold licenses and are authorized to pull permits for large-scale projects.

2. Scope of Work:

  • Handymen handle general maintenance and repairs.

  • Contractors specialize in specific trades or manage large projects involving multiple trades.

3. Cost:

  • Hiring a handyman is usually more affordable for smaller tasks.

  • Contractors charge higher rates due to their specialized skills and the complexity of their work.

4. Timeframe:

  • Handymen can often complete small jobs quickly.

  • Contractors may take longer, depending on the size and complexity of the project.

How to Decide Who to Hire

Ask Yourself These Questions:

  1. What is the scope of the project?

    • For minor repairs or tasks, hire a handyman.

    • For major renovations or specialized work, hire a contractor.

  2. Does the job require permits or inspections?

    • If yes, you’ll need a licensed contractor.

  3. What’s your budget?

    • For cost-effective solutions, handymen are ideal for small jobs.

    • Be prepared for higher costs with contractors for larger projects.

  4. Are there safety or legal considerations?

    • Complex projects with potential safety risks should be handled by a contractor.

Why Choose Full Service Handyman?

At Full Service Handyman, we specialize in a wide range of home repair and maintenance tasks, ensuring high-quality results for every project. When your project requires a licensed contractor, we’re here to guide you through the process and connect you with trusted professionals.

Why Work With Us?

  • Skilled handymen for minor repairs and installations

  • Expertise in assessing project scope and needs

  • Affordable, reliable, and efficient services

  • A network of licensed contractors for larger projects

Final Thoughts

Understanding the difference between a handyman and a contractor can help you make the right choice for your home improvement needs. While handymen are ideal for quick fixes and smaller tasks, contractors bring the expertise required for complex or large-scale projects. Need help deciding? Contact Full Service Handyman for expert advice and reliable services. Please call or text at 925-264-9646 for a free estimate.